Women's Economic Empowerment in South Asia
An examination of gender equality frameworks in South Asian economies, analyzing both individual outcomes and structural barriers to women's participation, designed to inform evidence-based policy and practice.
This presentation explores critical frameworks, evidence, and debates surrounding women's economic empowerment (WEE) in India and South Asia. We'll examine both individual outcomes and the systemic barriers that shape women's economic participation across the region.
Our analysis draws on the latest research and field insights to provide a comprehensive understanding of the challenges and opportunities in advancing gender equality in economic spheres. By understanding both micro and macro perspectives, we can develop more effective approaches to addressing gender gaps in the economy.
This May 2025 analysis offers a foundation for policy-makers, researchers, and practitioners working to promote women's economic rights and opportunities across South Asia.
VR
by Varna Sri Raman
Overview
This presentation examines women's economic empowerment in South Asia through both individual and structural lenses, highlighting the $411 billion economic cost of gender gaps and exploring the interplay between social, legal, and economic factors.
Critical Economic Impact
Women's economic participation is crucial for South Asian development, with the region losing approximately $411 billion annually due to gender gaps in economic participation.
Dual Perspectives
Our analysis balances individual empowerment approaches with the need for broader structural transformation in economic systems.
Interconnected Dimensions
We'll explore the critical interlinkages between social norms, legal frameworks, and economic opportunities that collectively shape women's empowerment.
This presentation offers a comprehensive examination of both challenges and promising interventions across South Asia, with particular focus on India as the region's largest economy and population center.
Section 1: Frameworks and Definitions
This section explores the theoretical foundations, historical development, and modern applications of women's economic empowerment frameworks that will guide our analysis throughout the presentation.
3
Theoretical Foundations
Examining core concepts that shape our understanding
Historical Evolution
Tracing how frameworks have developed over decades
3
Contemporary Applications
Current approaches used by major institutions and movements
In this section, we'll establish a clear understanding of what constitutes women's economic empowerment and how our conceptual frameworks have evolved over time. These foundations are essential for analyzing current challenges and identifying effective interventions.
The frameworks we explore will provide analytical tools for assessing both individual-level outcomes and structural barriers throughout the presentation.
Defining Women's Economic Empowerment
Women's economic empowerment is a multidimensional concept that encompasses decision-making power, resource control, equal market participation, and recognition of all forms of work, aimed at transforming gender-based power dynamics.
Power Relations
Transforming gendered power dynamics
Agency & Decision-Making
Control over economic choices and resources
Market Participation
Access and engagement in economic activities
Recognition of All Work
Valuing both paid and unpaid contributions
Women's economic empowerment extends far beyond simple labor force participation or income generation. At its core, WEE encompasses women's ability to make and act on economic decisions, control resources, and benefit from economic activities on equal terms with men.
This multidimensional concept recognizes that economic power is intertwined with social, political, and personal domains. True empowerment requires addressing both visible economic disparities and invisible power imbalances that structure economic relationships.
Evolution of WEE Frameworks
Women's economic empowerment frameworks have evolved from simple integration efforts to complex multidimensional approaches that address systemic barriers and power structures. This progression reflects a deeper understanding that true economic empowerment requires both individual opportunity and structural change.
1970s: Women in Development (WID)
Focused on integrating women into existing development processes. Emphasized women's productive roles and economic opportunities without challenging underlying structures.
1980s: Gender and Development (GAD)
Shifted focus to structural power relations between genders. Recognized that women's status couldn't improve without addressing systemic inequalities in institutions and social norms.
1990s: Rights-Based Approaches
Emphasized women's economic rights as fundamental human rights. Connected economic disempowerment to violations of basic entitlements to equality and non-discrimination.
2000s-Present: Multidimensional Frameworks
Integrated various dimensions of empowerment including resources, agency, achievements, and structural change. Recognized intersectionality of gender with other forms of discrimination.
This evolution reflects growing recognition that achieving women's economic empowerment requires addressing both individual constraints and systemic barriers embedded in economic, social and political structures.
Contemporary WEE Frameworks
Current women's economic empowerment frameworks vary in approach—from market-based solutions to rights-based perspectives—each emphasizing different aspects of economic participation, from asset ownership to unpaid care work recognition.
World Bank Framework
Centers on enhancing women's productivity, income, and agency through focus on physical capital, human capital, and voice. Emphasizes market-based solutions and policy reforms.
- Measures assets, capabilities, and opportunities
- Links to broader economic development goals
UN Women's Rights Approach
Grounds economic empowerment in human rights standards with focus on transforming unequal power relations. Emphasizes economic rights and structural change.
- Centers on gender equality as inherent right
- Addresses discrimination in economic systems
ILO Decent Work Framework
Focuses on quality of economic participation through decent work standards. Emphasizes formalization, social protection, and collective bargaining rights.
- Links labor rights to women's empowerment
- Addresses quality not just quantity of work
Feminist Economics Perspective
Challenges mainstream economic assumptions by valuing unpaid care work and questioning GDP-focused measures. Emphasizes social reproduction and wellbeing.
- Develops alternative measures of economic success
- Recognizes power dynamics in markets
These frameworks offer complementary perspectives on what constitutes meaningful economic empowerment, reflecting different priorities and approaches to achieving gender equality in economic spheres.
The Unpaid Care Lens
Unpaid care work represents a major barrier to women's economic participation in South Asia. The "4Rs" framework offers solutions through Recognition, Redistribution, Reduction, and Representation of care work.
Recognition
Acknowledging care work as economically valuable activity in policy and national accounts
Redistribution
Sharing care responsibilities more equally between genders and across society
Reduction
Decreasing time burden through infrastructure, technology and services
Representation
Ensuring care workers have voice in economic and social policy decisions
The "4Rs" framework developed by feminist economists provides a critical lens for addressing unpaid care work—a fundamental barrier to women's economic participation across South Asia. This framework recognizes that care responsibilities are not just private matters but economic and policy issues requiring systemic solutions.
With South Asian women performing 5-10 times more unpaid care work than men, addressing this imbalance is essential for enabling women's equal participation in the economy. Any effective WEE approach must consider how care responsibilities shape women's economic options.
Section 2: Current Status in South Asia
This section examines the paradox of South Asia's economic growth without corresponding women's inclusion, highlighting regional variations and untapped economic potential.
Regional Overview
Examining South Asia's position globally and the significant economic potential of closing gender gaps
Key Indicators
Analyzing specific dimensions including labor participation, quality of employment, entrepreneurship, and digital inclusion
Regional Variations
Understanding differences in women's economic status across countries and within India
This section provides a comprehensive picture of women's current economic status across South Asia, with particular focus on India. By examining various dimensions of economic participation, we can identify both progress and persistent challenges in the region.
The data reveals significant untapped economic potential, with South Asia having the world's lowest rates of women's economic participation despite decades of overall economic growth. This paradox of economic growth without women's inclusion represents one of the region's most pressing development challenges.
Regional Overview
South Asia has the world's largest gender gap in economic participation (23.6% vs global 47.4%), with significant country variations. Closing these gaps could add $3.3 trillion to regional GDP by 2030.
South Asia as a region faces the world's largest gender gap in economic participation, with female labor force participation averaging just 23.6% compared to the global average of 47.4%. This represents an estimated $411 billion annual economic loss from gender gaps regionally.
The picture varies dramatically across the region—from Nepal's high participation rate (influenced by counting subsistence agriculture) to extremely low rates in Pakistan and India. If current trends continue, South Asia will take over 195 years to close its gender gaps, the longest timeframe of any world region.
Closing these gaps could boost regional GDP by an estimated $3.3 trillion by 2030, representing one of the largest potential economic opportunities globally.
India: Economic Participation Trends
Despite strong economic growth over two decades, India's female labor force participation has declined from 30% to 23%, with significant urban-rural disparities and concentration in traditional sectors.
India presents a paradoxical case of declining female labor force participation despite robust economic growth over most of the past two decades. The female labor force participation rate has fallen from approximately 30% in the early 2000s to just 23% in 2023, making it one of the few countries globally where economic growth has not led to increased women's employment.
This trend shows significant urban-rural differences, with participation actually lower in urban areas (18%) compared to rural areas (25%). The sectoral concentration remains heavily skewed toward agriculture (55% of women workers), textiles/garments (18%), and domestic and care work (12%), with limited movement into emerging economic sectors.
Employment Quality in India
Women workers in India face significant challenges including high informal employment (91%), persistent wage gaps (19%), concentration in low-paying sectors (43%), and minimal access to social benefits (8%).
91%
Informal Workers
Percentage of women workers in the informal economy without legal protections or benefits
19%
Gender Wage Gap
Average pay difference between men and women for comparable work
43%
Sectoral Segregation
Percentage of women concentrated in just three low-paying economic sectors
8%
Social Protection
Proportion of women workers with access to comprehensive social security benefits
Beyond the challenge of low participation rates, the quality of women's employment in India reveals significant gender disparities. The overwhelming majority of women workers (91%) are in the informal economy, where they lack job security, legal protections, and social benefits.
Women face significant occupational segregation, with nearly half concentrated in low-paying, often precarious sectors. Even within the same occupations, the gender wage gap persists at 19% nationally, widening to 35% in some sectors. These quality gaps indicate that simply increasing the number of women working is insufficient without addressing fundamental inequalities in employment conditions.
Entrepreneurship Landscape
Despite comprising nearly half the population, women entrepreneurs in India face significant barriers including limited business ownership, restricted access to financing, and a substantial digital divide—challenges that persist even with targeted government support programs.
Limited Ownership
Women own only 20% of registered enterprises in India despite comprising 48% of the population. The majority of these are micro-enterprises with limited growth potential.
Financing Constraints
88% of women entrepreneurs access only micro-loans under ₹50,000 ($600), severely limiting their ability to scale operations. The credit gap for women-owned MSMEs exceeds $158 billion.
Digital Divide
Women have 33% less internet access than men, restricting their ability to participate in the digital economy. Only 27% of women entrepreneurs use digital tools for business compared to 57% of male entrepreneurs.
Women entrepreneurs face multiple barriers despite targeted government programs like Stand-Up India and MUDRA. While 68% of MUDRA micro-loans go to women, their average loan size is 35% smaller than those given to men, and graduation to larger loans remains rare.
Women-owned businesses tend to remain smaller, with average annual revenues 38% lower than male-owned enterprises in the same sectors, reflecting both initial capital constraints and ongoing operational challenges.
Unpaid Work Burden
Women in South Asia spend 5-6 hours daily on unpaid care work compared to less than 1.5 hours for men, creating a significant gender care gap that limits women's economic participation and represents an unrecognized contribution worth 10.5% of India's GDP.
The unpaid care burden represents one of the most significant structural barriers to women's economic participation across South Asia. In India, women spend an average of 352 minutes (nearly 6 hours) daily on unpaid care work, while men spend just 51 minutes—creating the highest gender care gap in the region.
This unequal distribution has substantial economic implications, with the value of women's unpaid care work estimated at over $300 billion annually (equivalent to 10.5% of India's GDP). The time poverty resulting from this care burden directly constrains women's ability to participate in paid work, education, and entrepreneurial activities.
The care burden varies significantly by class and location, with rural women and those from lower-income households facing even higher time demands due to limited infrastructure and household appliances.
Financial Inclusion Statistics
Despite improved bank account ownership among Indian women (78%), significant gaps persist in active usage (33%), digital financial services (28% gap), and credit access (60% lower approval rates than men).
Account Ownership vs. Usage
While 78% of Indian women now have bank accounts (up from 43% in 2014), only 33% actively use financial services beyond basic withdrawals. The gender gap in account ownership has narrowed to 6 percentage points, but the usage gap remains at 20 points.
Account dormancy rates for women are 8% higher than for men, with 45% of women's accounts showing no transactions in the past year beyond government transfers.
Digital Financial Inclusion
The digital financial inclusion gap stands at 28%, with only 35% of women using digital financial services compared to 63% of men. This gap is even wider in rural areas (37 percentage points) and among lower-income groups (42 percentage points).
Mobile phone ownership—a prerequisite for digital financial inclusion—shows a 19% gender gap nationally, rising to 33% in rural areas.
Credit Access
Women face 60% lower loan approval rates than men with similar credit profiles, and their average loan amounts are 33% smaller. Only 5% of women have formal credit histories compared to 22% of men, limiting their access to larger loans needed for business growth.
Alternative credit scoring models that consider women's different financial behaviors could potentially qualify 70% more women for formal credit.
Financial inclusion represents both significant progress and persistent challenges for women's economic empowerment in India. While basic access has improved dramatically, meaningful utilization of financial services lags behind, particularly for digital and credit products.
Digital Participation
India faces a significant digital gender divide, with large gaps in mobile internet usage (33%), smartphone ownership (45%), and digital literacy (40%). These disparities limit women's economic opportunities, particularly in rural areas, with substantial regional variations across states.
The digital gender divide remains a critical barrier to women's economic advancement in India. With a 33% gap in mobile internet usage and a 45% gap in smartphone ownership, women have significantly less access to digital economic opportunities. Only 14% of India's technology workforce is female, well below the global average of 28%.
The digital literacy gap stands at 40% between genders, with particularly wide disparities in rural areas and among older women. These digital divides limit women's participation in the fastest-growing sectors of the economy and their access to information, markets, and services that could enhance their economic prospects.
Regional variations are stark, with some states showing gender gaps in internet access exceeding 60%, while others have narrowed the gap to under 15% through targeted interventions.
Section 3: Structural Barriers and Challenges
Women in South Asia face interconnected structural barriers that limit economic participation, requiring multi-level interventions beyond individual solutions.
Legal & Policy Barriers
Formal constraints in laws and regulations
Social Norms
Cultural expectations limiting choices
Care Economy
Unequal distribution of household responsibilities
Human Capital
Gaps in education and skills development
Market Access
Barriers to resources and opportunities
Moving beyond individual constraints, this section examines the systemic and structural barriers that limit women's economic participation across South Asia. These interconnected challenges operate at multiple levels—from household to community to national policy—creating complex obstacles that individual-level interventions alone cannot address.
Understanding these structural dimensions is essential for developing comprehensive approaches to women's economic empowerment that can create sustainable change. Each barrier represents an area where targeted policy and programmatic interventions are needed.
Legal and Policy Barriers
Despite legal reforms on paper, women across South Asia face substantial barriers through discriminatory property laws, lack of protection in informal sectors, implementation failures, and restrictive regulations that limit economic opportunities.
Discriminatory Property Laws
Despite legal reforms, women face significant barriers in inheriting and controlling property. Implementation gaps mean only 13% of agricultural land is owned by women despite equal inheritance rights on paper.
Informal Sector Regulation
Labor laws primarily protect formal sector workers, leaving 91% of women workers in informal employment with limited legal protections against exploitation and harassment.
Implementation Failures
Gender-equal policies often fail in implementation due to capacity gaps, gender bias among officials, and complex procedures. Only 22% of women report being able to effectively access their legal entitlements.
Restrictive Regulations
Some labor regulations intended to protect women (like night work prohibitions) actually restrict their employment options. Sectors with high female employment often face greater regulatory burdens.
The legal and policy environment across South Asia contains both explicit discrimination and implicit biases that restrict women's economic opportunities. While significant legal reforms have occurred on paper, implementation gaps, enforcement challenges, and contradictory legal provisions create a complex landscape that disadvantages women in economic spheres.
Social Norms and Mobility
Social norms severely restrict women's economic participation in South Asia, with 60% needing permission to travel and 79% facing safety concerns that limit work options. Family disapproval and community expectations create additional barriers to women's employment outside the home.
Social norms operate as powerful constraints on women's economic participation across South Asia. In India, approximately 60% of women report needing permission from family members to travel outside their immediate neighborhood, significantly limiting their access to economic opportunities and services.
Safety concerns represent another major barrier, with 79% of women reporting that safety considerations restrict their work options, particularly regarding commuting distances and working hours. These mobility constraints directly impact job choices, entrepreneurial activities, and access to markets.
Community and family expectations regarding appropriate roles for women further limit economic choices, with 42% of women reporting family disapproval of their working outside the home. These normative constraints vary significantly by region, religious community, and caste, creating complex intersectional barriers.
Care Economy Constraints
Women in India face significant barriers to economic participation due to care responsibilities, including inadequate infrastructure, time poverty, and weak policy support. These constraints represent fundamental structural challenges to achieving gender equality in the workforce.
Insufficient Infrastructure
India invests only about 1% of GDP in care infrastructure, compared to 2-4% in countries with higher female labor participation. Public childcare services reach only 12% of eligible children nationally, with wide disparities in quality and accessibility.
The lack of eldercare services is becoming increasingly problematic as the population ages, with 83% of eldercare provided exclusively by family members, primarily women.
Time Poverty
Women in India have 5.8 fewer hours of discretionary time per week than men due to care responsibilities. This time poverty directly impacts their ability to participate in paid work, education, or community activities.
The time burden is particularly acute for women in households without basic amenities like piped water and cooking fuel, who spend an additional 1.5-2 hours daily on resource collection.
Policy Gaps
Maternity leave policies cover only 1.8% of women workers in the formal sector, leaving the vast majority without any paid leave for childbirth. Paternity leave remains minimal or non-existent, reinforcing gendered care roles.
Only 23% of workplaces with more than 50 employees comply with legal requirements to provide childcare facilities, with limited enforcement of existing regulations.
The care economy represents one of the most significant structural barriers to women's economic empowerment across South Asia. Without addressing the unequal distribution and insufficient support for care work, other interventions to promote women's economic participation will have limited effectiveness.
Educational and Skill Barriers
Despite progress in primary education parity, women in India face persistent gaps in secondary and tertiary education, limited STEM participation, gender-segregated vocational training, and significant digital skills disparities that collectively restrict their economic opportunities.
Educational Attainment Gaps
While primary education gender parity has been largely achieved in India, secondary education completion shows a persistent 12% gap. This widens to 23% at the tertiary level, with particularly large disparities in rural areas and among disadvantaged communities.
- Female secondary dropout rates: 17.3%
- Female tertiary enrollment: 28.5%
STEM and Technical Education
Women represent only 33% of STEM education participants nationally, with significant variation by field (43% in basic sciences but only 20% in engineering). This educational segregation directly shapes occupational segregation in the labor market.
- Women in engineering programs: 20%
- Women in IT education: 29%
Vocational Training
A 25% gender gap exists in vocational training participation, with women concentrated in a narrow range of traditionally feminine skills that often lead to lower-paying occupations. Only 8% of women in vocational programs train for emerging high-growth sectors.
- Gender segregation index: 0.68
- Women in non-traditional courses: 14%
Digital Skills
The digital skills gap stands at 35%, with particularly wide disparities in advanced digital competencies. Only 17% of women report confidence in using digital financial services independently, compared to 42% of men.
- Basic digital literacy among women: 38%
- Advanced digital skills among women: 12%
These educational and skill barriers significantly limit women's ability to access higher-paying jobs and adapt to changing labor market demands, particularly in the context of increasing automation and digitalization.
Market Access Challenges
Women entrepreneurs face four major barriers: limited business networks (62%), financial discrimination (52% credit rejection), value chain restrictions (38% lower revenues), and market expansion constraints (70% excluded from broader trade).
Limited Business Networks
62% of women entrepreneurs report lack of access to professional networks
- Restricted information about opportunities
- Limited mentorship connections
- Exclusion from informal business circles
Financial Barriers
52% face credit rejection despite viable business plans
- Higher interest rates (average 2.5% more)
- Greater collateral requirements
- Limited venture capital access (3.6% to women)
Value Chain Barriers
Women concentrated in lower-value segments with 38% lower revenues
- Limited supplier diversity initiatives
- Restricted access to procurement opportunities
- Challenges meeting certification requirements
Market Expansion Constraints
70% restricted from cross-border or national trade opportunities
- Complex regulatory compliance burdens
- Limited trade facilitation support
- Mobility and time constraints for market access
Women entrepreneurs and producers face significant barriers in accessing markets on equal terms with men. These market access challenges restrict women's ability to grow their enterprises beyond micro-scale operations and limit their economic returns despite significant time and effort investments.
Addressing these market barriers requires both demand-side interventions (supplier diversity, procurement targets) and supply-side support (trade facilitation, network building) to create more equitable market access.
Political Economy Constraints
Women face systemic barriers in economic governance due to limited representation, gender-blind policies, uneven trade impacts, and insufficient gender budgeting implementation.
Representation Gaps
Women constitute only 15% of economic decision-making bodies in India, including treasury, central bank, planning commissions, and trade ministries. This representation gap means women's economic priorities receive limited attention in major policy decisions.
Gender-Blind Macroeconomics
Fiscal, monetary, and trade policies rarely incorporate gender impact assessments. Tax structures, infrastructure investments, and sector prioritization often inadvertently disadvantage sectors and work arrangements where women predominate.
Trade Liberalization Effects
Trade agreements and liberalization have affected women-dominant sectors differently than male-dominant ones. Textile and agriculture sectors with high female employment have faced increased competition without adequate adjustment support.
Gender Budgeting Limitations
Despite 18 years of gender budgeting in India, implementation remains focused on women-specific programs rather than mainstream economic policies. Only 5% of total budget undergoes meaningful gender analysis, limiting transformative potential.
The broader political economy creates structural constraints that individual-level interventions cannot address. Without women's representation in economic governance and gender-responsive macroeconomic policies, systemic barriers to women's economic empowerment will persist despite targeted programs and projects.
This section examines key theoretical tensions, implementation challenges, and future directions in women's economic empowerment discourse, highlighting how different perspectives shape approaches in this field.
Section 4: Key Debates in WEE Discourse
Theoretical Tensions
Examining competing frameworks and approaches to women's economic empowerment
Implementation Debates
Analyzing contentious questions about program design and prioritization
Future Directions
Exploring emerging challenges and evolving paradigms in the field
This section explores the major theoretical and practical debates that shape approaches to women's economic empowerment. These debates reflect differing priorities, values, and theories of change among practitioners, policymakers, and researchers in the field.
Understanding these debates is essential for developing nuanced approaches that can navigate complex tradeoffs and respond to the diverse needs of women across different contexts. By examining competing perspectives, we can identify areas of consensus while recognizing where legitimate differences in approach exist.
Growth vs. Empowerment
The relationship between economic growth and women's empowerment is complex and non-linear. Evidence challenges the assumption that growth automatically improves women's economic status, suggesting the need for targeted gender-inclusive policies.
The Growth Hypothesis
Traditional economic approaches have assumed that economic growth naturally leads to women's empowerment through expanded opportunities. This perspective emphasizes:
- Market expansion creates new jobs
- Rising incomes improve women's status
- Development naturally reduces gender gaps
- Focus on GDP and headline indicators
Evidence From India
India's experience challenges simplistic growth-to-empowerment assumptions with:
- "Jobless growth" for women despite GDP increases
- FLFP declined while economy grew at 6-8%
- Economic expansion concentrated in male-dominated sectors
- Growth coincided with rising time poverty for women
Empowerment-Centered View
Alternative approaches prioritize quality of participation and power relations:
- Economic participation must enhance agency
- Quality of work matters more than quantity
- Growth patterns and distribution are critical
- Multidimensional measurement beyond income
This debate raises fundamental questions about how we measure progress in women's economic empowerment. Evidence increasingly suggests that the relationship between growth and women's empowerment is neither automatic nor straightforward—requiring specific policies that ensure growth patterns are gender-inclusive and empowering.
Individual Agency vs. Structural Change
WEE strategies must balance individual empowerment with structural transformation. Evidence shows combining personal agency development with collective action and systemic change yields the most sustainable impact.
Structural Transformation
Changing economic and social systems
Collective Action
Women organizing for shared interests
Capability Enhancement
Building skills and resources
Individual Agency
Personal choices and actions
A central tension in WEE approaches concerns the appropriate balance between enhancing individual women's agency and addressing broader structural constraints. Individual-focused interventions (skills training, microfinance, entrepreneurship) can create immediate opportunities but may place responsibility for change on women themselves without addressing systemic barriers.
Evidence from South Asia suggests individual-level interventions show limited sustainable impact when implemented alone. The most successful programs combine individual capacity building with efforts to transform constraining structures—from household power dynamics to market discrimination to policy environments.
Collective approaches that build women's solidarity and shared power have demonstrated greater effectiveness in challenging structural barriers than purely individual interventions. This suggests the need for multi-level strategies that connect individual empowerment to broader social and economic transformation.
Formal vs. Informal Economy Focus
91% of women workers in India are in the informal economy. WEE strategies debate whether to prioritize formalization or improve informal working conditions, with each approach offering distinct advantages and challenges.
With 91% of women workers in India employed in the informal economy, a key debate concerns whether WEE strategies should prioritize formalization or focus on improving conditions within informal work. Formalization approaches emphasize legal protections, social security benefits, and regulated working conditions that come with formal employment.
However, critics note that formalization can sometimes exclude women who cannot meet formal requirements or manage the compliance costs. Rigid formal employment may also fail to accommodate women's need for flexibility given their care responsibilities. In some contexts, poorly designed formalization efforts have pushed women out of economic activities altogether.
Alternative approaches focus on extending protections and benefits to informal workers without requiring full formalization. These include strategies like portable benefits, simplified regulations for micro-enterprises, recognition of informal collectives, and sector-specific protections in industries with high female employment.
Technology: Enabler or Barrier?
Technology presents a double-edged sword for women's economic participation: creating new flexible opportunities through digital platforms while simultaneously posing risks through automation and digital divides. Without intentional design and policy, technological advances may widen rather than close gender gaps.
New Opportunities
Digital platforms and technologies are creating flexible work opportunities that can accommodate women's time constraints. E-commerce has reduced market access barriers for women entrepreneurs, with platform-based businesses showing 34% higher female participation than traditional retail.
Digital financial services have increased women's financial privacy and control, with 28% reporting greater decision-making over finances when using digital tools versus cash.
Automation Threats
Women face disproportionate risks from automation, with 11 million female jobs in India at high risk of displacement. Jobs with high female concentration (data processing, textiles, retail) show automation potential of 52-65%, compared to 41% for male-dominated sectors.
Re-skilling programs reach only 22% of at-risk women workers, creating potential for technology-driven increases in gender gaps.
Digital Divide Concerns
The gender digital divide threatens to reproduce and amplify existing inequalities. Only 33% of internet users in India are women, creating significant barriers to accessing digital economic opportunities.
Digital skills disparities mean that even when women have access, they often engage with technology in more limited ways, using fewer services and advanced features.
Platform Economy
Digital platforms offer flexible opportunities but often with limited protections. Women in platform work report 19% lower earnings than male counterparts and face specific challenges including safety concerns, rating biases, and limited advancement paths.
Platform design often fails to account for women's needs, with only 8% of digital platforms having specific features addressing female users' constraints.
The technology debate highlights the need for gender-responsive digital policies that maximize opportunities while actively addressing risks of exclusion or exploitation. Without intentional design and regulation, digital technologies may exacerbate rather than reduce economic gender gaps.
Urban vs. Rural Priorities
Women in South Asia face distinctly different economic challenges based on geographic context. Urban areas show higher education but lower participation rates, while rural women participate more but in lower-value work. These differences demand context-specific rather than uniform policy approaches.
Women's economic challenges differ significantly between urban and rural contexts in South Asia, raising debates about appropriate prioritization in policy and programming. The urban paradox of higher education but lower labor force participation differs from rural contexts where participation is higher but predominantly in vulnerable, low-return activities.
Infrastructure needs vary dramatically, with urban women prioritizing safe transport and affordable housing while rural women face more basic service gaps. Migration patterns create distinct challenges, with urban migrant women navigating new environments while rural "left-behind" women manage increased responsibilities without corresponding decision-making authority.
Effective WEE approaches must be contextualized to these different realities rather than applying uniform solutions across urban and rural settings. This requires greater geographic targeting and adaptation of interventions to address the specific barriers most relevant in each context.
Section 5: Government Initiatives in India
The Indian government has deployed a multifaceted approach to women's economic empowerment spanning policy frameworks, financial programs, education, digital initiatives, and business support measures, though implementation challenges persist.
Policy Framework
Overarching strategies and legal foundations
Financial Programs
Interventions for financial inclusion and access
Capability Development
Skill building and educational initiatives
Digital Initiatives
Technology-focused approaches for inclusion
Business Support
Entrepreneurship and enterprise development
The Government of India has implemented numerous initiatives aimed at enhancing women's economic participation and empowerment. This section examines major government programs across multiple domains, assessing their design, reach, and effectiveness in addressing identified barriers.
While these initiatives demonstrate increasing policy attention to women's economic empowerment, implementation challenges and design limitations have affected their impact. Understanding both the potential and constraints of government approaches is essential for identifying opportunities to strengthen public sector efforts.
Policy Landscape
India has developed a progressive policy framework for women's economic empowerment through national policies, gender-responsive budgeting, and legal reforms, though implementation challenges persist across these initiatives.
National Policy for Women (2016)
The NPW established women's economic empowerment as a priority focus area, shifting from welfare to rights-based approaches. The policy specifically addresses women's work participation, ownership rights, and entrepreneurship development.
Key provisions include promotion of asset ownership, skill development aligned with market needs, support for women in informal sectors, and recognition of unpaid care work. Implementation is coordinated through the National Mission for Empowerment of Women.
Gender Responsive Budgeting
Institutionalized in 2005, GRB requires all ministries to report allocations for women through a Gender Budget Statement. Currently 42 ministries/departments participate, with annual allocations reaching approximately 5.5% of total government expenditure.
The effectiveness varies significantly across departments, with stronger implementation in social sectors but limited application in economic ministries. Outcome monitoring remains a challenge, with focus primarily on allocation rather than impact.
Legal Reforms
The Maternity Benefit Amendment Act (2017) extended paid maternity leave from 12 to 26 weeks and mandated childcare facilities in establishments with 50+ employees. However, it covers only formal sector workers (less than 10% of women workers).
The Equal Remuneration Act prohibits gender discrimination in recruitment and pay, but enforcement mechanisms remain weak with only 19% of complaints resulting in penalties. Proposed labor code reforms aim to streamline multiple labor laws but have faced implementation delays.
India's policy landscape shows significant evolution over the past two decades, with increased recognition of women's economic contributions and rights. However, implementation gaps and limited coordination across agencies have constrained the transformative potential of these policy frameworks.
Financial Inclusion Programs
India has made significant progress in women's financial inclusion through various government initiatives, though challenges persist in moving beyond basic access to meaningful financial participation and growth opportunities.
Pradhan Mantri Jan Dhan Yojana
Launched in 2014, PMJDY has opened 258 million women's accounts, significantly narrowing the gender gap in basic account ownership from 20% to 6%. The program includes zero-balance accounts, accident insurance coverage, and overdraft facilities.
MUDRA Loans
The Micro Units Development and Refinance Agency provides collateral-free loans to micro-enterprises in three tiers (up to ₹50,000, ₹5 lakh, and ₹10 lakh). Women constitute 68% of beneficiaries but receive primarily the smallest tier loans with limited progression to larger amounts.
Stand-Up India
This scheme facilitates loans between ₹10 lakh and ₹1 crore to at least one SC/ST borrower and one woman borrower per bank branch. Since 2016, it has supported over 138,000 women entrepreneurs with dedicated relationship managers and simplified procedures.
Banking Guidelines
The Reserve Bank of India has issued gender-responsive banking guidelines including simplified KYC norms for women, targets for lending to women entrepreneurs, and requirements for disaggregated data reporting. Implementation varies significantly across financial institutions.
Financial inclusion programs have significantly improved women's access to basic financial services, but utilization gaps remain substantial. While 78% of women now have bank accounts, only 33% actively use financial services beyond basic withdrawals, indicating the need for programs addressing usage barriers beyond basic access.
Credit programs have reached millions of women but remain concentrated at the micro level, with limited progression pathways to larger financing needed for enterprise growth. The recent push toward digital financial services offers new opportunities but requires addressing the digital gender divide to avoid exacerbating exclusion.
Skill Development Initiatives
India has implemented comprehensive skill development programs with women's quotas, though significant gender gaps in job placement and sector diversity persist despite training millions of women nationwide.
30%
Reserved Seats
Minimum quota for women in National Skill Development Mission programs
14,604
Training Centers
Industrial Training Institutes nationwide with women's quotas
2.5M
Rural Women
Trained under Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Grameen Kaushalya Yojana
43%
Placement Gap
Difference between male and female job placement rates after training
India has established an extensive architecture for skill development with specific provisions for women's participation. The National Skill Development Mission mandates a minimum 30% quota for women across programs, while the Industrial Training Institute network has established 14,604 centers nationwide with reserved seats for women trainees.
Rural-focused programs like Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Grameen Kaushalya Yojana have trained 2.5 million rural women, with particular focus on school dropouts and young women from disadvantaged communities. STEM education initiatives include the Vigyan Jyoti program promoting science education for girls and women-focused modules in engineering education.
However, significant challenges persist in translating training into employment, with a 43% gender gap in placement rates after training completion. Gender segregation in course selection remains high, with women concentrated in traditionally feminine sectors with lower earning potential. Addressing these gaps requires greater focus on comprehensive support beyond technical training, including soft skills, mentorship, and employer engagement.
Digital Empowerment Programs
India has implemented multiple digital initiatives to bridge the gender gap in technology access, including rural literacy programs, mobile training, peer learning models, and e-marketplace opportunities. These efforts aim to address significant disparities in digital access while building women's capacity to participate in the digital economy.
Digital Literacy Mission
The Pradhan Mantri Gramin Digital Saksharta Abhiyan aims to train one person per household in digital literacy, with 40% of beneficiaries being women. Over 53 million rural citizens have been trained, with dedicated women-only batches to address social barriers to participation.
Women-Focused Campaigns
The Ministry of Electronics and IT has launched targeted digital literacy campaigns for women, including mobile-based training modules that accommodate time constraints and mobility limitations. These programs focus on practical applications like accessing government services and financial platforms.
Internet Saathi
This public-private partnership between Google, Tata Trusts and the government trained over 83,000 women as digital ambassadors who in turn reached 30 million rural women across 3.3 lakh villages. The program focuses on sustainable digital skill transfer through peer learning models.
E-Marketplace Access
Government e-marketplace (GeM) has established a "Womaniya" initiative prioritizing procurement from women-owned businesses. Special onboarding assistance and targeted contract opportunities have increased women vendors on the platform by 76% over three years.
Digital initiatives have expanded significantly in recent years, recognizing both the opportunities and risks of the digital transformation for women's economic empowerment. These programs aim to address the 33% gender gap in mobile internet usage and the 45% gap in smartphone ownership that currently limit women's participation in the digital economy.
Evaluations of these programs indicate positive impacts on women's digital comfort and usage, but significant challenges remain in addressing deeply rooted social norms and financial constraints affecting technology adoption. The most successful models have combined digital access with use cases directly relevant to women's economic activities and needs.
Entrepreneurship Support
Government initiatives like WEP, Mahila E-Haat, startup incubation programs, and trade facilitation centers provide comprehensive support to women entrepreneurs through digital platforms, mentorship, market access, and specialized training.
The Women Entrepreneurship Platform (WEP) established by NITI Aayog provides a unified portal for information, services, and connections, serving over 50,000 registered entrepreneurs. It offers mentorship, funding facilitation, compliance assistance, and market connections through public-private partnerships.
Mahila E-Haat, a digital marketplace specifically for women entrepreneurs, showcases products from over 28,000 women-owned businesses across 31 categories. It eliminates intermediaries and provides direct market access with dedicated marketing support. Women-focused startup incubation programs offer specialized support in 17 sectors, including subsidized workspace, seed funding, and regulatory navigation assistance.
Trade facilitation centers for women artisans have been established in 78 craft clusters, providing training, design input, quality control, and market linkages for traditional craft producers. These centers have shown strong impact in enhancing incomes for rural women entrepreneurs in cultural industries, with average income increases of 42% reported by participants.
Implementation Challenges
Government WEE initiatives face significant challenges including budget underutilization, fragmented coordination, output-focused monitoring, and uneven geographic implementation.
Outcomes vs. Outputs
Limited focus on measuring meaningful change
Fragmented Approach
Poor coordination across implementing agencies
Budget Execution
Significant underspending of allocated funds
Geographic Disparities
Uneven implementation across regions
Despite ambitious program designs, implementation of government WEE initiatives faces significant challenges. Budget execution shows consistent gaps between allocation and actual spending, with an average 18-24% underspending in women-focused programs. In some schemes, utilization falls below 60% of allocated funds due to complex disbursement procedures and capacity constraints.
Limited coordination across ministries results in duplicative efforts and policy inconsistencies. While the National Mission for Empowerment of Women was established to ensure convergence, in practice most programs operate in silos with separate targeting, monitoring, and implementation structures.
Monitoring systems focus primarily on output metrics (number of beneficiaries, amount disbursed) rather than outcome measures of actual empowerment or economic improvement. Only 12% of programs have rigorous impact evaluation components, limiting evidence-based improvements. Geographic coverage shows significant disparities, with implementation concentrated in a subset of states and districts based on administrative capacity rather than need.
Section 6: Private Sector Approaches
The private sector contributes to women's economic empowerment through workplace policies, innovative financial products, digital solutions, and strategic partnerships. These approaches vary in scope but offer promising practices for scaling impact.
Corporate Practices
Internal policies and workplace initiatives
Financial Innovation
New approaches to capital access
Technology Solutions
Digital tools addressing women's constraints
Cross-Sector Collaboration
Public-private partnerships for impact
The private sector plays a crucial role in advancing women's economic empowerment through both internal practices and market-facing innovations. This section examines private sector approaches across multiple dimensions—from workplace policies to financial products to technology solutions that address women's specific economic constraints.
While corporate initiatives vary widely in scope and commitment, we highlight promising practices that demonstrate potential for scale and impact. Understanding these approaches helps identify opportunities for greater private sector engagement and cross-sector collaboration to advance women's economic empowerment goals.
Corporate Programs
Leading Indian companies are advancing women's economic empowerment through four key approaches: targeted diversity initiatives that increase female representation, supplier diversity programs that support women-owned businesses, flexible work policies that address care responsibilities, and mentorship networks that facilitate career development.
Diversity & Inclusion Initiatives
Leading Indian companies have established specific targets for women's representation, with the top 100 BSE firms averaging 23% female board membership (up from 7% in 2014). Companies like Tata, Wipro, and Infosys have implemented comprehensive gender diversity strategies with regular public reporting.
These initiatives include targets for recruitment, promotion, and retention, with accountability mechanisms tied to management performance evaluation. Companies with structured D&I programs show 24% higher female retention rates.
Supply Chain Diversity
Supplier diversity programs that prioritize procurement from women-owned businesses are growing, with 35 major Indian corporations implementing formal programs. The Confederation of Indian Industry has established certification standards for women-owned enterprises to facilitate identification.
Leading examples include HUL's Shakti program integrating rural women entrepreneurs into distribution networks and Walmart's Women Entrepreneurship Development Program, which has trained 11,000 women suppliers.
Work Flexibility & Return Programs
Recognizing care responsibilities, 62% of large companies now offer flexible work arrangements, though implementation varies widely. Returnship programs specifically designed for women re-entering the workforce after career breaks are showing promising results.
These programs, pioneered by companies like IBM, Godrej, and Genpact, include specialized onboarding, skill refresher courses, and phased re-entry options. Participants show 68% retention rates after two years, significantly above average.
Mentorship Networks
Industry-wide mentorship initiatives connect women across companies and sectors. Programs like CII's Indian Women Network and FICCI's FLO Mentorship Cell have engaged over 15,000 women in structured mentoring relationships.
Company-specific programs like Accenture's "High-Tech Women" provide intensive mentorship for women in technical roles, resulting in 35% higher promotion rates for participants compared to non-participants.
Corporate programs show significant variation in scope and impact, with leading companies demonstrating comprehensive approaches while others implement more limited measures. Evidence suggests programs with senior leadership commitment, specific targets, and accountability mechanisms show stronger results than more general diversity statements.
Financial Innovations
Targeted financial solutions are transforming women's economic participation through gender-focused investments, specialized fintech platforms, alternative credit scoring, and innovative funding structures, addressing unique needs while creating substantial market opportunities.
Gender Lens Investing
The gender lens investing market in India is growing at 24% annually, reaching $6.2 billion in assets. Investment vehicles explicitly target businesses that are women-led, create products for women, or implement strong workplace equity practices.
Women-Focused Fintech
Specialized fintech platforms address women's specific financial needs, including savings tools that accommodate irregular income patterns, simplified interfaces designed for lower digital literacy, and privacy features that enhance women's financial autonomy.
Alternative Credit Assessment
Innovative credit scoring models use alternative data points relevant to women's economic activities. These models incorporate non-traditional indicators like utility payment history, supplier relationships, and even psychometric evaluations to overcome women's limited formal credit histories.
Blended Finance
Blended finance structures combine commercial capital with development finance and philanthropic funds to de-risk investments in women entrepreneurs. These models have unlocked $457 million for women-owned businesses in frontier markets across South Asia.
Financial innovations are helping overcome persistent barriers in women's access to and usage of financial services. Private financial institutions are increasingly recognizing women as a distinct and valuable market segment with specific needs and preferences rather than treating them as a uniform group.
The most successful innovations address multiple constraints simultaneously—combining product design, delivery channels, and auxiliary services to overcome both supply and demand-side barriers. The potential for scale remains significant, with women-focused financial innovations currently reaching less than 15% of the addressable market in India.
Technology Solutions
Specialized technology solutions are addressing women entrepreneurs' unique challenges through digital marketplaces, remote work tools, business management applications, and safety-focused technologies, though impact remains constrained by the digital gender divide.
Digital Platforms
E-commerce and service marketplaces designed for women entrepreneurs address market access barriers. Platforms like Sheroes, Heydeedee, and WEConnect provide specialized features for women sellers, including simplified interfaces, built-in logistics, and safeguards against harassment.
Remote Work Technologies
Remote work tools help women balance economic participation with care responsibilities. Companies like Fleximoms and HerSecondInnings specialize in remote opportunities for women, while collaboration platforms incorporate features like flexible scheduling and asynchronous options.
Business Management Tools
Mobile-based business management applications designed for low-literacy users help women micro-entrepreneurs formalize operations. Apps like OKCredit, Khatabook, and Udaan include voice interfaces, simplified record-keeping, and features for managing household-business boundaries.
Safety Applications
Safety-focused technologies address mobility constraints for working women. Apps like Safecity, Safetipin, and My SafetyPin map unsafe areas, provide emergency features, and collect crowdsourced data on harassment, helping women navigate public spaces more confidently.
Technology solutions are increasingly addressing women's specific economic constraints, though the impact remains limited by the digital gender divide. Companies developing these solutions are finding that women-centered design approaches—involving women users throughout development—yield significantly higher adoption and retention rates.
Public-Private Partnerships
Public-private partnerships leverage complementary capabilities to address women's economic empowerment challenges through initiatives like digital training, entrepreneurship support, and supply chain integration. These collaborations combine government reach, private sector expertise, and civil society implementation.
Project Her&Now
A collaboration between GIZ (German development agency) and the Ministry of MSME providing comprehensive support to women entrepreneurs in underserved regions. The program combines government reach with private sector expertise in business development. Impact: 1,200+ women-led businesses supported across 12 states, with 73% reporting revenue growth within one year.
Internet Saathi
Partnership between Google, Tata Trusts, and state governments to bridge the digital gender divide in rural India. The program trains women as digital ambassadors who then train other women in their communities. Impact: 83,300 Saathis trained, reaching over 30 million rural women across 3.3 lakh villages, with 71% continuing to use internet for economic activities.
WeConnect International
Collaboration between multinational corporations, the Ministry of Commerce, and women business associations to integrate women-owned businesses into corporate supply chains. Impact: Certified 650+ women-owned businesses and facilitated $75 million in contracts with participating corporations over three years.
4
SEWA-Microsoft Initiative
Partnership between the Self-Employed Women's Association and Microsoft providing digital skills to informal sector women workers. Combines SEWA's grassroots reach with Microsoft's technical expertise. Impact: 170,000 women trained, with 48% reporting new income streams from digital skills.
Strategic partnerships between public, private, and civil society stakeholders demonstrate potential for addressing complex WEE challenges by leveraging complementary capabilities. Successful PPPs typically combine government reach and legitimacy with private sector technical expertise and efficiency, often with civil society organizations providing last-mile implementation capacity.
These partnerships work best when roles and responsibilities are clearly defined, with shared metrics and accountability mechanisms. While promising, PPPs face sustainability challenges when shifting from pilot to scale due to coordination costs and competing institutional priorities.
Section 7: Civil Society and Community Models
Civil society organizations drive women's economic empowerment through grassroots innovations, collective enterprises, and community-based solutions that address both economic and social barriers facing marginalized women.
Grassroots Organizing
Women-led community organizations have developed innovative models for economic empowerment that build on local knowledge and address context-specific barriers.
Collective Enterprise
Cooperative and collective business models help women overcome individual constraints through shared resources, knowledge, and risk distribution.
Community Solutions
Locally-developed approaches to structural barriers like childcare, market access, and social norms demonstrate the power of community innovation.
Civil society organizations and community-based approaches play a crucial role in women's economic empowerment across South Asia. These models often reach women excluded from formal government and private sector initiatives, particularly those facing multiple forms of marginalization.
This section explores grassroots innovations that have demonstrated effectiveness in addressing women's economic constraints through collective action and community-based solutions. These approaches often combine economic interventions with social empowerment strategies to address interconnected barriers.
Self-Help Group Movement
India's SHG movement has empowered 72 million women through financial inclusion, enterprise development, and social change activism, demonstrating impacts beyond economics into political and social empowerment.
72M
Women Members
Total women participating in 6.6 million SHGs across India
$9.2B
Credit Linkages
Annual bank lending facilitated to women's groups
82%
Repayment Rate
Average loan repayment performance of women's SHGs
45%
Income Increase
Average reported household income growth for SHG members
The Self-Help Group movement represents India's largest community-based approach to women's economic empowerment, with 72 million women organized in 6.6 million groups nationwide. Initially focused on savings and credit, SHGs have evolved into platforms for multiple dimensions of empowerment, including enterprise development, service delivery, and social change activism.
The National Rural Livelihoods Mission has formalized government support for SHGs, providing capacity building, bank linkages, and market connections. Research shows SHG members experience an average 45% increase in household income along with significant improvements in financial capability and decision-making authority.
Beyond economic outcomes, SHGs have demonstrated significant "spillover effects" into political empowerment, with members 24% more likely to run for local office and 43% more likely to participate in community governance. These groups have also become important platforms for addressing social issues like gender-based violence, child marriage, and caste discrimination, integrating economic and social dimensions of empowerment.
Collective Enterprise Models
Collective enterprises enable women to overcome barriers through shared resources and market power, with successful models including producer companies, SEWA's integrated approach, sector-specific collectives, and value chain integration strategies.
Producer Companies
Women-owned farmer producer companies have grown significantly, with 425 all-women FPCs registered nationwide. These provide economies of scale, increased bargaining power, and formal market access for women agricultural producers who previously operated informally.
Examples like Vanangana Farmer Producer Company in Uttar Pradesh show how collective organization helps overcome gendered barriers in agriculture, with members reporting 34% higher prices received for their products compared to individual sales.
SEWA's Integrated Model
The Self-Employed Women's Association pioneered an integrated approach to organizing informal women workers that combines economic collectives with union-style advocacy. Their 2.1 million members include street vendors, home-based workers, and domestic workers.
SEWA's cooperatives demonstrate how collective enterprise can formalize informal work while maintaining flexibility. Their sister insurance, banking, and training organizations provide essential support services.
Sector-Specific Collectives
Specialized collective enterprises have emerged in sectors with high female concentration. The Lijjat Papad cooperative employs 43,000 women with annual sales of over ₹1,600 crore. In textiles, organizations like Rangsutra connect 4,000+ artisans to markets while preserving traditional crafts.
In waste management, SWaCH cooperative in Pune has organized 3,500 waste pickers, increasing their incomes by 300% while providing formal recognition of their work.
Value Chain Integration
Advanced collective models are moving beyond production to integrate across value chains. Mann Deshi Farmer Producer Company not only aggregates produce but operates processing units and direct retail channels that capture greater value for women producers.
These integrated models create more sustainable enterprises by reducing dependency on external market intermediaries and capturing more value within women-controlled organizations.
Collective enterprise models demonstrate how women can overcome individual constraints through shared resources, knowledge, and market power. These approaches are particularly important in contexts where women face multiple barriers to independent entrepreneurship, including limited asset ownership and mobility restrictions.
Grassroots Innovations
Women's collectives across South Asia have developed innovative, community-based solutions to overcome economic barriers through childcare cooperatives, digital service centers, alternative markets, and accountability initiatives.
Community Childcare Solutions
Women's collectives have developed innovative models to address the care burden constraint. Sangini Childcare Cooperative in Ahmedabad operates 34 childcare centers serving 3,400 children of informal workers through a worker-owned model that provides affordable, flexible care while creating decent employment for providers.
Rural Digital Hubs
Women-operated rural digital service centers help bridge the digital divide. Grameen Information Centers in Maharashtra train rural women to operate as "digital sahayaks" providing essential e-services to their communities while earning income through service fees. 420 centers serve 210,000+ villagers.
Local Market Creation
Women's groups have established alternative market models when mainstream access is limited. Weekly women's markets (mahila haats) organized by federation of SHGs in Jharkhand create direct producer-consumer connections, eliminating exploitative intermediaries while creating safe selling spaces.
Community Monitoring
Women-led accountability initiatives ensure effective implementation of economic programs. Social Audit Committees in Rajasthan trained 3,600 women to monitor MGNREGA implementation, reducing corruption and ensuring women receive entitled wages. Payment delays decreased by 68% in participating panchayats.
These grassroots innovations demonstrate the capacity of women's organizations to develop contextually appropriate solutions to complex barriers. By combining local knowledge with collective action, these approaches often succeed where top-down interventions have failed.
Many of these innovations have inspired larger policy and program developments, showing the important role of community experimentation in developing effective approaches to women's economic empowerment. The most successful scale through a combination of organic replication, NGO support, and eventual policy adoption.
Section 8: Evidence on What Works
This section examines evidence-based approaches for women's economic empowerment in South Asia, highlighting effective intervention models, financial inclusion strategies, skills development, and solutions for unpaid care work.
1
1
Program Design
Evidence on effective intervention models
2
2
Financial Services
What works in financial inclusion
Capability Building
Effective approaches to skills and training
Care Solutions
Evidence on addressing unpaid work
This section synthesizes evidence from rigorous evaluations and research studies to identify approaches that have demonstrated effectiveness in promoting women's economic empowerment across South Asia. Understanding "what works" is essential for designing evidence-informed interventions and policies that deliver meaningful results.
We examine both the content of interventions (what is provided) and delivery approaches (how it is provided) that influence outcomes. The evidence suggests that context matters significantly—interventions must be adapted to specific constraints and opportunities in local environments rather than applying one-size-fits-all solutions.
Comprehensive Approaches
Integrated interventions addressing multiple constraints yield significantly better outcomes than single-focus programs, with sustained engagement and joint household approaches further enhancing effectiveness.
Evidence consistently shows that integrated interventions addressing multiple constraints simultaneously outperform single-focus programs. Combined approaches that address both economic and social dimensions of empowerment demonstrate 43% greater impact on women's income and 38% greater impact on decision-making authority compared to single-component interventions.
Program time horizons significantly influence outcomes. Interventions with sustained engagement over 3+ years show substantially better results than short-term programs, particularly for outcomes related to agency and decision-making. This suggests that while economic gains may appear relatively quickly, shifts in power relations and gender norms require longer timeframes.
Joint household approaches that engage both women and men show 34% improved outcomes in women's economic decision-making compared to women-only programs. This is particularly true in contexts with strong gender norms where male gatekeepers can either enable or block women's economic participation and control of resources.
Successful comprehensive programs typically sequence and layer interventions appropriately—often beginning with building core capabilities before introducing more complex components like enterprise development or market integration.
Financial Services Evidence
Financial services show greatest impact when basic accounts are enhanced with complementary interventions. Digital solutions increase women's economic activity by 21%, while financial capability programs work best when paired with relevant products. Group-based models consistently outperform individual approaches.
Beyond Basic Access
Research conclusively shows that basic account ownership alone is insufficient for meaningful empowerment. A seven-state study in India found no significant impact on women's economic activity or decision-making from account ownership without complementary interventions to address usage barriers.
However, when basic accounts are combined with financial literacy training and direct deposit of government benefits, account usage increases by 52% and women report 36% greater control over transferred funds compared to cash disbursements.
Digital Financial Services
Digital financial services show particularly strong evidence of impact, increasing women's economic activity by 21% compared to conventional services. The privacy and convenience of mobile money services enable women to maintain greater control over resources.
A randomized evaluation of mobile banking in Madhya Pradesh found that women with mobile accounts saved 42% more than the control group and were significantly more likely to work outside the home (increase of 14 percentage points) due to greater financial independence.
Financial Capability
Financial literacy interventions show mixed results when delivered alone, but when paired with access to relevant products, they increase usage by 38%. Effective approaches go beyond traditional classroom training to include experiential learning, peer support, and digital tools.
The timing of financial capability programs also matters significantly—just-in-time financial education tied to specific decisions or life events shows 72% greater knowledge retention and application compared to standalone training.
Group-based models consistently show stronger outcomes through peer effects. Women in group-based microfinance show 28% higher enterprise investments and 23% higher likelihood of challenging restrictive norms compared to individual borrowers. These social connections appear to provide both accountability and collective power that enhances economic outcomes.
Skills and Training Impact
Skills training is most effective when combined with mentorship (40% income impact) and when focusing on digital skills (33%). Programs that align with market demand and integrate soft skills significantly outperform technical-only approaches.
Skills training programs show significantly stronger outcomes when they align directly with market demand. Market-aligned training increases income by 15-28% compared to supply-driven approaches. The most effective programs involve employers in curriculum design and include guaranteed interview opportunities upon completion.
Evidence shows that combining technical skills with soft skills/life skills components is crucial for women's employment outcomes. Programs including communication, negotiation, and workplace navigation skills show 24% greater employment outcomes than purely technical training, particularly for women entering male-dominated fields where workplace gender dynamics present additional challenges.
Digital skills yield 33% higher returns on investment than traditional skills, but must be tailored to women's specific constraints. Successful digital training programs use women trainers, provide practice devices, and incorporate relevant use cases. The impact is particularly strong when digital skills are integrated with entrepreneurship support.
Mentorship and networks amplify training effectiveness by 40% according to multiple studies. These connections provide crucial guidance, emotional support, and access to opportunities that help women navigate gender-specific barriers in employment and entrepreneurship. Formal mentorship programs with structured curriculums show stronger results than informal approaches.
Care Solutions Evidence
Evidence shows care interventions significantly boost women's economic participation: childcare increases employment by 15-26%, employer-supported care improves retention by 28%, and well-designed parental leave policies enhance workforce retention by 20%.
Addressing the unpaid care burden shows some of the strongest evidence of impact on women's economic participation. Childcare provision increases women's employment by 15% on average across studies, with effects as high as 26% in urban areas. Proximity matters significantly—childcare centers within 1-2km of homes increase usage by 38% compared to more distant facilities.
Employer-supported care yields 28% higher workforce retention for women with children and reduces absenteeism by 40%. Companies implementing childcare support report positive returns on investment through reduced turnover costs and increased productivity, with breakeven periods averaging 1.5-2 years.
Community-based models show particular promise for reaching informal workers overlooked by employer-based or market solutions. Mobile creches at construction sites and community-managed centers in urban informal settlements have demonstrated significant impact on both women's earnings and children's developmental outcomes.
Beyond childcare, evidence on eldercare solutions is emerging as a critical need with aging populations. Early studies of community eldercare initiatives in Kerala show women's time spent on eldercare reduced by 30%, with corresponding increases in income-generating activities.
Parental leave policies increase women's workforce retention by 20% when well-designed. Most effective are policies that combine adequate duration (6+ months), reasonable compensation (at least 67% of wages), and non-transferable paternity components that encourage redistribution of care responsibilities.
This section presents strategic recommendations for advancing women's economic empowerment in South Asia through coordinated action across government policies, targeted strategies, implementation approaches, and improved measurement systems.
Section 9: Recommendations and Future Directions
Policy Priorities
Key government actions to enable women's economic empowerment
Targeted Strategies
High-impact approaches for specific dimensions of WEE
Implementation Approaches
Effective coordination and accountability mechanisms
Measurement and Learning
Enhanced data and evidence generation for informed action
Building on the evidence and analysis presented, this final section outlines strategic recommendations for advancing women's economic empowerment in India and South Asia. These recommendations aim to address both immediate barriers and longer-term structural constraints to create an enabling environment for women's full economic participation.
The recommendations reflect the need for coordinated action across multiple stakeholders—governments, private sector, civil society, and international organizations—with each playing distinct but complementary roles. While ambitious, these recommendations are grounded in evidence of what works and respond to the specific contextual challenges identified in the South Asian context.
Policy Priorities
Strategic government actions focused on gender-responsive recovery, care infrastructure, legal reform, and gender budgeting to address structural barriers to women's economic empowerment.
Gender-Responsive Recovery
Implement economic recovery policies that address women's disproportionate pandemic losses. Target support to female-dominated sectors, extend social protection to informal workers, and ensure women benefit equally from stimulus investments.
Care Infrastructure Investment
Increase public investment in care infrastructure to 2% of GDP (from current 1%). Expand public childcare services with sliding scale fees, develop elder care systems, and incentivize employer-provided care through tax benefits and mandates.
Legal Reform
Reform discriminatory laws affecting women's economic rights, particularly in property, inheritance, and family law. Strengthen sexual harassment protections across all work settings and enhance enforcement mechanisms for existing equality laws.
4
Gender Budgeting
Expand gender budgeting beyond women-specific schemes to mainstream economic policies. Implement outcome-based metrics for gender budget reporting and require gender impact assessments for all major economic initiatives.
Policy priorities should focus on addressing structural barriers that individual programs alone cannot overcome. While targeted programs for women are important, mainstreaming gender considerations into core economic policies—fiscal, monetary, trade, infrastructure—is essential for addressing systemic constraints.
Effective implementation requires strengthening institutional mechanisms for gender equality, including enhancing the mandate and resources of national women's machinery, establishing cross-ministerial coordination mechanisms, and creating transparent accountability systems with civil society participation.
Digital Transformation Strategy
A multi-layered approach to women's digital empowerment focusing on universal access, skills development, gender-responsive applications, and female leadership in technology to overcome economic barriers.
3
Digital Leadership
Women shaping digital future
Gender-Responsive Applications
Technology addressing women's needs
3
Digital Capabilities
Education and training for effective use
Universal Access
Affordable connectivity for all women
A comprehensive digital transformation strategy for women's economic empowerment must address multiple layers simultaneously. At the foundation, universal digital access policies should establish gender-specific targets with affordability measures like subsidized data plans and devices for low-income women, and investment in last-mile connectivity for underserved areas.
Building on this foundation, digital capability development requires both formal education (integrating digital skills into school curricula with gender-sensitive pedagogies) and community-based approaches (peer learning models like Internet Saathi that address women's practical constraints and build confidence).
Digital financial services require specific regulatory frameworks that balance innovation with protection, including simplified KYC requirements that accommodate women's ID challenges, consumer protection for first-time users, and requirements for sex-disaggregated data reporting by providers.
Women-focused digital platform development should be prioritized through innovation funds, incubation support, and procurement preferences. The most effective platforms address specific constraints women face in economic participation, such as time poverty, mobility limitations, and market access barriers.
Entrepreneurship Ecosystem
A comprehensive ecosystem for women entrepreneurs requires information access, reimagined credit assessment, inclusive public procurement policies, and targeted export promotion to overcome gender-specific barriers.
Developing an inclusive entrepreneurship ecosystem requires addressing information asymmetries through a comprehensive information and networking portal for women entrepreneurs. This centralized platform should provide regulatory guidance, funding options, market intelligence, and mentorship connections with multilingual interfaces and offline access points for women with limited connectivity.
Financial institutions should implement reimagined credit assessment methodologies that account for women's different business and financial patterns. Alternative data sources like rental payments, supplier relationships, and psychometric evaluations can help overcome limited formal credit histories, potentially qualifying 70% more women entrepreneurs for formal financing.
Public procurement can drive demand through supply chain diversity requirements, with a recommended 30% target for women-owned businesses phased in over five years. Simplified tendering procedures, unbundled contracts, and advance payment options can make government contracts more accessible to women-owned firms.
Export promotion specifically targeting women-owned businesses should include specialized training on international standards, trade facilitation services, and export credit guarantees. Targeted trade missions and international networking opportunities can help women entrepreneurs overcome information and connection barriers to international markets.
Labor Market Reforms
Comprehensive reforms focusing on social protection, pay equity, anti-discrimination enforcement, and job quality metrics to address women's specific needs in the labor market.
Expanding Social Protection
Develop portable benefit systems accessible to informal workers regardless of employment status or workplace. Contributory models with government subsidies for low-income workers can make these systems financially sustainable while reaching women in diverse work arrangements.
Priority benefits include health insurance, maternity support, and old-age security—the protection gaps most affecting women's economic security and labor market decisions.
Equal Pay Mechanisms
Implement equal pay certification programs requiring companies above a certain size to demonstrate fair compensation practices. Iceland's model, which reduced its gender pay gap to 4.5%, provides a proven approach that could be adapted to the Indian context.
Complementary pay transparency requirements would mandate reporting of gender pay data, creating accountability while protecting individual privacy.
Anti-Discrimination Enforcement
Strengthen enforcement of existing anti-discrimination laws through specialized labor inspection units focused on gender equality. These units should have mandate to investigate complaints, conduct proactive audits, and impose meaningful penalties.
Legal assistance programs specifically for women workers would improve access to justice by providing guidance, representation, and support throughout complaint processes.
Job Quality Metrics
Incorporate job quality measures into employment programs and policies, moving beyond simple job creation numbers. These metrics should include earnings adequacy, benefits, working conditions, hours stability, advancement potential, and voice/representation.
Performance evaluation of government employment initiatives should include gender-specific quality indicators to prevent steering women into lower-quality positions.
Labor market reforms should balance protection with flexibility to address women's specific needs and constraints. Rather than a one-size-fits-all approach, policies should recognize the diversity of women's work arrangements while ensuring basic economic security and rights across all categories of employment.
Data and Measurement
Comprehensive gender data systems are vital for policy development, requiring standardized time-use surveys, gender-disaggregated economic metrics, qualitative empowerment measures, and intersectional analysis frameworks.
Time-Use Data
Regular time-use surveys should be institutionalized to measure and value unpaid care work. These surveys should use standardized methodologies allowing for international comparison while capturing context-specific activities relevant to South Asian settings.
Disaggregated Economic Data
All major economic data collection must include gender disaggregation as a standard practice. This includes labor force surveys, enterprise censuses, financial inclusion metrics, and digital economy indicators to enable detailed gender analysis.
Qualitative Empowerment Measures
Complement quantitative indicators with standardized measures of agency, decision-making, and empowerment. Tools like the Women's Empowerment in Agriculture Index provide models that can be adapted to different economic sectors.
Intersectional Analysis
Data systems should enable analysis along multiple dimensions beyond gender, including caste, religion, disability, and geographical location to identify women facing multiple forms of economic marginalization.
Improved data systems are essential for both policy design and accountability. Current data gaps obscure gender disparities and limit evidence-based policymaking. National statistical offices require capacity building and dedicated resources to collect, analyze and disseminate gender-sensitive economic data.
Beyond government data, innovative approaches like citizen-generated data, big data analytics, and private sector partnerships can provide complementary insights, particularly for rapidly changing economic dimensions and informal economic activities where traditional data collection is challenging.
Research Agenda
The Women's Economic Empowerment research agenda prioritizes four key areas: longitudinal studies to evaluate long-term impacts, examination of technology's effects on gender equality, analysis of macroeconomic policies through a gender lens, and research on effective male engagement strategies.
Long-Term Impact Evaluation
Current evidence on WEE interventions is limited by short evaluation timeframes, typically 1-3 years. Priority research should include longitudinal studies tracking outcomes over 5-10 years to understand sustainability of economic gains and potential delayed effects on social dimensions.
These studies should examine how initial economic changes translate into broader empowerment over time, including spillover effects on next-generation outcomes and potential backlash or adaptation in gender norms.
Technology Effects
Research on technology's gendered impacts must move beyond access questions to examine how specific technologies affect women's economic roles, inclusion, and power relations. Priority areas include automation impacts on female-dominated sectors and potential displacement or opportunity effects.
Studies should identify mechanisms for ensuring that emerging technologies like AI and platform economies reduce rather than amplify gender inequalities, examining policy, design, and implementation factors.
Macroeconomic Policy
There is limited evidence on how mainstream economic policies—fiscal, monetary, trade, and structural adjustment—differentially affect women across economic roles as workers, producers, and care providers. Research should develop gendered macroeconomic models to better predict policy impacts.
Studies examining natural experiments from policy changes can generate evidence on how taxation, public spending patterns, interest rates, and trade arrangements affect gender economic gaps.
Men's Engagement
Research on effective approaches for engaging men as supporters of women's economic empowerment remains insufficient. Studies should identify intervention models that effectively shift male attitudes and behaviors regarding women's economic roles.
Priority questions include examining household cooperation models, effective messaging approaches, and programs that address masculine identity concerns that may drive resistance to women's economic advancement.
This research agenda highlights knowledge gaps that, if addressed, would significantly enhance the effectiveness of WEE approaches. Research partnerships between academic institutions, implementing organizations, and government agencies can maximize both rigor and relevance for practical application.
Multi-stakeholder Approach
Successful women's economic empowerment requires coordinated action across government, private sector, civil society, and international organizations, with each playing distinct complementary roles to create sustainable change.
1
1
Government Role
Policy, legislation, and investment
- Enabling legal environment
- Public investment in infrastructure
- Gender-responsive public services
- Enforcement of protections
Private Sector Role
Corporate practices and market solutions
- Workplace gender equality
- Supply chain diversity
- Product/service innovation
- Industry standard-setting
Civil Society Role
Advocacy and community innovation
- Grassroots mobilization
- Policy advocacy
- Accountability monitoring
- Service delivery innovation
International Role
Knowledge exchange and standards
- Technical assistance
- Cross-country learning
- Global standard setting
- Catalytic financing
Effective women's economic empowerment requires coordinated action across stakeholders, each leveraging their comparative advantages. Government policy coordination should be strengthened through high-level institutional mechanisms with authority across ministries and adequate resources. These mechanisms should include meaningful participation from women's organizations in both design and monitoring.
Private sector commitments require clear accountability frameworks to translate pledges into practice. Industry-wide initiatives like certification systems, reporting standards, and peer benchmarking can create positive competitive dynamics for gender equality. Civil society monitoring and advocacy provide essential external accountability, while innovation incubated by non-governmental organizations often pioneers approaches later adopted at scale.
Regional Cooperation
Regional cooperation across South Asia can accelerate women's economic empowerment through coordinated efforts in cross-border trade, skill recognition, policy exchange, and collective advocacy in global forums.
Cross-Border Trade
Facilitate women's participation in intra-regional trade
Skill Recognition
Develop shared qualification frameworks
Policy Exchange
Share successful WEE approaches regionally
4
Collective Voice
Joint advocacy in global economic forums
Given shared challenges and opportunities, regional cooperation can accelerate progress on women's economic empowerment across South Asia. Cross-border trade facilitation specifically for women entrepreneurs should include simplified procedures for small-scale trade, border market infrastructure designed for women's needs, and information services on cross-border opportunities.
Regional skill recognition frameworks would enhance labor mobility while protecting women migrant workers' rights. Common certification standards and qualification recognition would facilitate safe and beneficial migration while reducing vulnerability to exploitation. This is particularly important for care work and domestic service, where many South Asian women migrants are concentrated.
Knowledge sharing on effective WEE policies can accelerate learning across countries. The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) could establish a dedicated knowledge platform on women's economic empowerment, facilitating comparative research, policy dialogue, and practitioner exchange across member states.
Collective advocacy on global economic governance would strengthen South Asian influence in international forums where trade, finance, and labor standards are established. A coordinated regional position on gender-responsive economic policies could more effectively influence global frameworks than individual country advocacy.
Measuring Success
Traditional metrics fall short in measuring women's economic empowerment. Comprehensive frameworks should assess not just participation rates but also work quality, agency in decision-making, and economic security to capture meaningful progress.
Measuring progress on women's economic empowerment requires moving beyond simplistic indicators like labor force participation to more nuanced frameworks that capture both quantitative and qualitative dimensions. A comprehensive measurement approach should examine not just whether women participate in the economy, but how they participate and whether that participation translates into meaningful empowerment.
Quality of work indicators must complement basic employment statistics, examining formality, earnings, benefits, working conditions, and advancement opportunities. These dimensions provide a more accurate picture of whether economic participation is empowering or exploitative.
Agency and decision-making measures are essential but frequently overlooked in economic monitoring. Standardized indicators examining control over economic resources, voice in household financial decisions, and autonomy in work choices should be incorporated into regular economic surveys.
Economic security and resilience metrics recognize that vulnerability to shocks can undermine even significant economic gains. Measures should examine women's ability to withstand financial shocks, access social protection, and maintain economic stability through various life transitions.
Conclusion: Transformative Change
Transformative women's economic empowerment requires structural changes, integrated approaches connecting economic and social dimensions, sustained long-term investment, and women's leadership in economic decision-making at all levels.
4
Structural Transformation
Changing systems, not just symptoms
Integrated Approaches
Combining economic and social dimensions
Sustained Commitment
Long-term vision with adequate resources
4
Women's Leadership
Centering women's voices in economic governance
Achieving transformative change in women's economic empowerment requires addressing both individual constraints and structural barriers. Individual-focused interventions that build women's capabilities and resources must be complemented by systemic reforms that create enabling environments for women's economic participation and leadership.
The evidence clearly demonstrates that economic and social dimensions of empowerment are inseparable. Narrow economic approaches that ignore social norms, care responsibilities, and power relations will have limited effectiveness. Truly transformative approaches engage with these interconnected dimensions to create sustainable change.
Sustained investment with a long-term vision is essential, as meaningful changes in economic structures and gender relations develop over generations, not project cycles. This requires moving beyond short-term programmatic thinking to embed women's economic empowerment in core institutions and systems.
Ultimately, women's leadership in economic decision-making at all levels—from households to corporate boardrooms to macroeconomic policy—is both a means and an end of empowerment. When women shape economic systems and policies, these systems better respond to women's needs and priorities, creating a virtuous cycle of increasing empowerment.